preview

Analysis Of Where Are You Going Where Have You Been And Smooth Talk

Good Essays

Connie’s Fate in the Hands of the Reader
(INTRO): The most crucial and pivotal part of a storyline is the ending. Oftentimes, a movie and a book based on the same storyline will differ in a multitude of ways. Consequently, the entire interpretation of a story is based on the ending. This concept is expressed in the intricate and intriguing plots of the short story “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” by Joyce Carol Oates and the movie Smooth Talk. (THESIS): The ending of the short story is more effective than the ending of the movie because it leaves more to the imagination with its graphic scenes that emphasize Connie’s complex relationship with her mother and show a transformation in Connie’s personality.
(Imagination)Sometimes a …show more content…

For she becomes disoriented and watches herself venture outside, as if she were not in her own body. Everything around her, including her home and her land, seems remarkably unfamiliar, but Oates writes that “she was going to it” (Oates 204). This quotation is ambiguous in itself; what might going to the land symbolize? Connie may very well just be taken from her home, as what happens in the movie. It may, furthermore, be plausible that she is going to be killed. She may become one with the land, buried down underneath the dirt. Arnold does not truly care about Connie, as shown when he calls brown-eyed Connie his “sweet little blue-eyed girl” (Oates 204). Considering his lack of genuine interest in Connie, there may be no limit what he is willing to do to Connie to get what he wants. The story ends abruptly and on a cliffhanger with its significance up for debate in the air.
( Detailed Scene)The more descriptive an author is in his or her writing the better. The more a reader knows about the characters and what is going on in the story can help him or her interpret the storyline better. In the short story, Oates goes into great detail when describing Connie’s final encounter with Arnold Friend. Connie’s thoughts and feelings are expressed much more vividly than are portrayed in the film. Connie’s thought process of perceiving Arnold as a friend to a foe is shown. Oates is very clear about Connie’s two-sided personality, for Connie has always loved attention.

Get Access