preview

Electoral College Literature Review

Decent Essays

Literature Review of the Electoral College’s Relevance The Electoral College disenfranchises numerous voters annually, and its seemingly decreasing relevance is highly debated today. While the United States Constitution outlines the Electoral College, many claim it reduces the voter’s power. On this issue I have summarized, compared, and evaluated six sources to reach my own verdict and assess if the Electoral College should be abolished for a national popular vote. Persuasive Articles: Against the Abolition of the Electoral College Summaries In the article “Why the Electoral College is more relevant today than ever before,” politician Spenser Mestel argued the Electoral College is important today, and removing it would threaten America’s carefully balanced democracy. The author utilized a unique perspective explaining the effects if the Electoral College was eliminated; he suggested if a single popular vote was instituted, presidential candidates would appeal to the largest class: the middle class. Additionally, Mestel (2016) concluded “class could become the new fault line.” The remaining portion recognized both arguments and conceded the Electoral College is not perfect but a sure way to elect a president. Richard A. Posner wrote “In Defense of the Electoral College” to advocate keeping the Electoral College. He took a Constitutional approach and stated how the Electoral College chooses a presidential candidate. Posner continued to explain five reasons the

Get Access