preview

Mr. Antolini's Role In Catcher In The R

Decent Essays

Lectures and Cynicism Mr. Antolini’s Role in Catcher in the Rye In J.D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye, Holden seeks out Mr. Antolini due to his similarity to D.B., but soon discovers that Mr. Antolini is just like the other adults in his life, thereby reaffirming his cynicism towards adults. The distraught Holden seeks a solace from Mr. Antonili due to the preconceived notion that Mr. Antolini’s opinions would parallel his own, only to be completely mistaken. Moreover, the interaction between Holden and Mr. Antolini is similar to that of Mr. Spencer and Holden’s interaction, showing that Mr. Antolini is just like the other adults in his life. In this notion, one can observe why Holden tries to prevent his loved ones from growing up. …show more content…

Antolini’s lecturing of Holden changes Holden’s perception of Mr. Antolini from being similar to the affable D.B. to being similar to the authoritative Mr. Spencer, reaffirming Holden’s cynicism towards adults. As Holden is complaining about his Oral Expression class at Pencey, he states that it is more entertaining when one “digresses” from the subject when they are giving a speech (278). Holden expected that Mr. Antolini would understand and agree with him, as his views were usually in line with Holden, such as their disappointment in D.B. for going to write for Hollywood (235). However, Mr. Antolini surprises Holden by asking, “You don’t care to have someone stick to the point when he tells you something”(239)? By imploring Holden to explain his statement, Mr. Antolini parallels Mr. Spencer in the way that he turns the conversation about his failing out of Pencey on Holden. Mr. Spencer makes Holden explain to him why he failed the class (16). Holden, who has trouble with articulating his thoughts, tends to seize up when this occurs, making the conversations doubly unpleasant. “Oh I don’t know,” Holden replied to Mr. Antonili, “I didn’t feel much like explaining. I was feeling sort of dizzy or something, and I had a helluva headache all of a sudden. I really did” (238). Holden was so uncomfortable with Mr. Antolini’s turning the conversation on him that he was physically sick. This parallels to when Mr. Spencer was conversing with him, Holden recounts “All of the …show more content…

Antolini serves to reaffirm Holden’s cynicism towards adults. Mr. Antolini simply wanted to help him, but his advice was a redundancy to Holden, who only saw that Mr. Antolini was just like every other adult in his life, against him. This perhaps explains Holden’s cynicism towards adults, as he had gone to Mr. Antolini with expectations of a solace, but he soon discovered that Mr. Antolini was just as against him as Mr. Spencer. Holden believes that nearly every adult in his life is against him, creating a cynicism towards adults, which perhaps is the root of why he is trying to prevent his loved ones from reaching

Get Access