preview

Performance Management

Better Essays

Performance Assessment plays an important role in human resource management processes. However, factual evidence shows that there is a high rate of assessment failures. One of reasons leading to this issue is the illogical design of performance assessment forms. This essay firstly outlines the performance management technique using in the Performance Appraisal Form Template issued by Businessballs (www.businessballs.com). This essay will then analyse its strengths and weaknesses related to assessment validity, reliability and felt-fairness. Finally, this essay will discuss some aspects where this instrument can be re-designed to improve its validity, reliability and felt-fairness. This appraisal form, also referred to as an instrument, …show more content…

This explicitly requires "supervisors and subordinates to negotiate mutually agreeable goals" (Youngcourt et al 2007, p. 321). The "problem solving" style review meeting between assessees and assessors could satisfy this requirement. Through open discussions supervisors could help subordinates identify and correct their goals as well as address performance problems (Sheilds 2008). As a result, the effectives of MBO approach would be ensured. Besides the strengths mentioned above, there are several weaknesses existed in this instrument. Firstly, the scope of this instrument is wide. It could be applied to both managerial and non-managerial positions. Using the same criteria and the same rating scale (section A4 and B4) for both the positions, this instrument could compromise construct and content validity. This is because different positions require different competencies (Lounsbury, Steel, Gibson & Drost 2008). Consequently, criteria and measures which are valid for the one position may not valid for the other. For example, competencies leadership, problem solving and decision making could determine the success of a manager while technical competencies could be important for a line worker (Salaman, Storey & Billsberry 2005). The second weakness is that this instrument could compromise reliability. The use of self assessment source and supervisory assessment source on the one side could reduce rating errors relating to the single supervisory assessment source, it

Get Access