preview

Respect For Aboriginal People Essay

Decent Essays

Respect for Aboriginal People in The Justice System
There is a dearth of respect for Aboriginal people in the Canadian justice system shown by the lack of regard for the personal past of these people during their trials, and the unfair and unjust sentencing for their crimes which will not help them in the long run. In the article Canada’s prisons are the new ‘residential schools’ by Nancy Macdonald, she states that Andy Peekeekoot, a man from Saskatchewan's Cree nation, was not fairly tried because the judge on his case did not consider the implications of his past childhood. “Before he turned two, Peekeekoot was made ward of the state after being found starved and neglected. Both parents were violent alcoholics and drug users . . . he was twelve when he attempted suicide, after being sexually abused” …show more content…

Andy Peekeekoot was not born a violent person, but the way he was raised and his experiences as a child influenced the way he acts as an adult, and the court must take that into consideration when trying an Aboriginal person. Nancy Macdonald mentions in her article that because Andy Peekeekoot is named a dangerous offender, he can be kept behind bars indefinitely. His lawyer believes that prison will not do him any good. “None of this, Hrycan says, will do him any good: ‘He’ll never get out. We’ve put someone in jail for the rest of his life for waving a four-inch knife” (Macdonald L76-78).One of the main points of Judge John Reilly’s TED Talk was that if you are not going to lock them up forever, do not lock them up at all. Andy Peekeekoot is now a changed man; he is married, and has not had a charge for violence in 9 years. Unfortunately, due to his dangerous offender designation, he will most likely never leave prison, when all he did was wave a knife. This shows that in the Canadian justice system, Aboriginals are not being treated with dignity, because of the ridiculous and unjustified amount of time they

Get Access