I think Miller decided to remove this scene from the play because it would kind of spoil the upcoming plot and ruin the suspense for the readers. As mentioned in the deleted scene, Proctor intends to go to court and "ruin" Abigail for all her lies and corruption in the Salem witch trials. The dialogue between the two during their conversation gives away what is going to happen in the next act and that may be why Arthur Miller decided to take the scene out of the
Others could find more emotions shown in metaphors to show a deeper meaning. In the third act of the play, Proctor confesses that he is an adulterer and he explains why he would not lie about it. When Proctor said that Abigail was the person he was having an affair with it shows that his name is now tainted. Since his respectable name is tainted it has shown his sincerity in his claim that Abigail had an affair with
In Act Ⅱ Scene 2 of The Crucible, a 1953 play by the Arthur Miller, Abigail Williams, the antagonist, meets John Proctor, the protagonist, in the forest at night, where John asks Abigail to free his wife in court the next day, or otherwise he will expose their affair in public to ruin her. This fast-paced short scene portrays Abigail as pious and possessed, which contradicts the impression given by previous scenes. Most importantly, the scene reveals the crucial plan of Proctor which he is planning to use to take down Abigail. By excluding the scene, Miller eliminates the unfavourable danger of jeopardizing the credibility of the characters due to the inconsistency of descriptions, heightens the dramatic effect when Proctor confesses in
Throughout the play, Proctor is surrounded by those who wish to do him harm. He sticks out in the Salem society, because he is not a regular church goer. In a Puritan town where the church attendance was recorded, skipping church was unacceptable. They thought if someone didn't go to church regularly they were less christian. This plays heavily when the court judges Proctor. Proctor goes in front of the court in a final attempt to save his wife, but before he can speak, the court tries to destroy his word. The court officials know that there probably aren't witches in Salem at this point, but if they are proved wrong, they would be responsible for the death of innocent people. Proctor figures out that the court knows they probably can't trust Abigail, but do nothing about it. So when Abigail and her gang drive Mary insane, and against Proctor, the court accepts it. They condemn proctor to death, and Proctor loses it, saying that “ You know it
When writing a book every author aims to perfect it; often times along the way parts are amended, removed, or added. As in the tragedy, The Crucible, by Arthur Miller, he wrote Act 2, Scene 2, but before the play was released, he removed it; it was not his intent to destroy it entirely as it was additionally added to the appendix of the book. The scene between Proctor and Abigail should not be attached to the book. Moreover, the scene should not be added because John Proctor’s darker side should not be revealed. Along with this, Abigail is no longer just spiteful and cunning, but crazy, unpredictable, and evil. Her personality and inner desires should be more shrouded so the reader can speculate and fill in the blanks. Additionally, the supplemented scene would have been repetitive; Proctor and Abigail's complicated relationship is already defined in the book.
This speech shows that Proctor is blaming himself for this tragedy. Proctor's guilt still continues about his affair with Abigail and he is also now guilty for hesitating to act earlier.
Next, Tituba was not whipped into confession in the play, whereas she was in the movie. This was most indefinitely added to show that the profession was typically not made willingly. One had to be forced one way or another into confessing, to save their skin or their life. Also, around the time of this scene is one where Abigail and John Proctor have a conversation. In the movie, Abigail kisses John Proctor and he throws her off of him, which did not occur in the play. This was no doubt inserted to show the audience that Abigail was oddly and obsessively lusting over the man while he was making a sincere attempt to get over her.
At the trial, Proctor no longer tried to protect himself and admits to having an affair with Abigail, explains
This courtroom scene never occurred in the play but was added for more dramatic effect. Miller gives George Jacobs a more substantial character by adding this scene to the movie. John Proctor’s children are never seen in the play, but in the movie they see their mother, Goody Proctor, being arrested and taken after being accused of witchcraft. Seeing the boys tell their mother goodbye evokes a strong emotion in the movie. In the play, Goody Proctor asks her husband to, “Tell the children I have gone to visit someone sick” (74). At the end of the movie, Abigail accuses Reverend Hale’s wife of witchcraft. Judge Danforth tells her that she is mistaken. Abigail will say and do anything to get people out of her way in an attempt at winning the love of John Proctor. She does this because Reverend Hale believes Abigail is a scam and she knows he is on to her. This scene only occurs in the movie to portray how wicked and evil Abigail is, again for dramatic effect. There is no mention of Reverend Hale’s wife in the
Proctor's desire to preserve his good name earlier keeps him from testifying against Abigail, leading to disastrous consequences. Now,
He feels that he can never be with Abigail again. He is haunted by this because when he talks to her, he is nervous. “Abby, I may think of you softly from time to time. But I will cut off my hand before I’ll ever reach for you again. Wipe it out of mind. We never touched” (Page 22). In this quote, two betrayals are revealed by Proctor. First, his betrayal of his wife and second his betrayal of Abigail. These two betrayals are crucial to the play seeing as it is due to Proctor’s betrayal of his wife, by cheating on her, and his betrayal of Abigail, by leaving her without taking responsibility, that initiated the conflict. Furthermore, because Proctor is not willing to admit his deceit, both he and his wife got caught in disorder. Ultimately, Proctor’s betrayal and dishonesty lead to his downfall.
Throughout the play, Proctor struggles with his honor as he changes from viewing it as his reputation to believing it is based on his own private moral of truth. The isolated Puritan community in which Proctor lives forces him to try and achieve a pious and perfect lifestyle, which ultimately pressures him into lying about his affair with Abigail in order to maintain a good reputation. This view changes in the courtroom, when Proctor becomes extremely frustrated with the lies and deceit that Abigail is telling the judges, Proctor screams in anger, “I beg you sir, I beg you - see her what she is… She thinks to dance with me on my wife’s grave! And well she might, for I thought of her softly. God help me; I lusted, and there is a promise in such sweat. But it is a
The school day finished without a further peep from Gideon, to Judy’s surprise. She bid Angie a good-bye as the ocelot was picked up by her parents. Judy smiled, as her best friend climbed into the back seat, waving to her all the way to the end of the lot. Judy was about to make her way to the car until a large paw grabbed her mouth and made is so she couldn’t scream, another went around her waist picking her up. She was thrown again a metal pole, what she presumed to be the tetherball pole that was for gym class.
In the original version of The Crucible, published in 1953, a second scene for Act II was written but Arthur Miller decided to take it from the future editions that came after that time. A reason Arthur Miller might have removed this scene from the play was that it showed the readers too much information, which would have given the readers too much about what would happen later on in the play and it might have had disinterested the readers into continuing reading. The Act II scene, which was taken off from the play, would have changed the outlook that the read had on The Crucible and its characters, like Abigail’s character. Abigail would have been viewed differently after this scene because they would feel pity for her. Arthur Miller made
Miller made the right decision in removing Act 2 Scene 2 as it would have distracted the reader from the larger purpose of power and hysteria in the play and have instead introduced a new conflict of genuine insanity. In the deleted scene, a different side of Abigail is shown, one that is delusional and seems to care for Proctor. In a wishfully disturbing manner, Abigail promises to Proctor that, “I will make you such a wife when the world is white again… From yourself I will save you”, and repeatedly states her belief that her purpose was to “scrub the world clean” of all the hypocrites and eventually be rewarded with Proctor as a husband. This caring and desperate side of Abigail contradicts the selfish and manipulative persona that is seen
John Proctor was a “farmer in his middle thirties… strong, even-tempered, and not easily led” (20). Proctor’s reputation was good and he was a well respected man around Salem. The play shows that Proctor’s past involved him having an affair with Abigail. Now in the present, Proctor is conflicted with the fear of being labeled as an adulterer for his past. Proctor’s fear weakens his morality in the court when he has to explain the situation to Judge Danforth. Proctor tells Danforth that he “has known her” (110) and that Abigail wishes to “dance with me (Proctor) on my wife's grave” (110). Although the fear of being labeled as an adulterer and being charged of lechery, Proctor believes that telling the truth is the right thing to do. Proctor realizes that the Salem witch trials have gone to far and are merely just attempts from Abigail to get Proctor all to herself. Proctor’s fear initially holds him back from telling the court the reason why Abigail is accusing everyone and acting strange. Later on the unveiling of his affair with Abigail results in the trials being questioned but it also fuels the deadly fate of