preview

Staying Put Ethos Pathos Logos

Decent Essays

Question 1: Scott Russell Sanders uses the appeal of logos throughout the passage, Staying Put: Making a Home in a Restless World, by appealing to logic, persuading the audience based on sense and reason. In this direct example from the text, “From the beginning, our heroes have been sailors, explorers, cowboys, prospectors, speculators, backwoods ramblers, rainbow-chasers, vagabonds of every stripe,” logos is introduced through excessive detail, giving more than plenty of examples in which we create our heroes to be free-spirits. This detail creates a sense of reason in which it’s logical to assume Americans like to move around based off the list of heroes presented. “In our national mythology, the worst fate is to be trapped on a farm, in …show more content…

In lines three through six, “From the beginning, our heroes have been sailors, explorers, cowboys, prospectors, speculators, backwoods ramblers, rainbow-chasers, vagabonds of every stripe” Sanders uses detail to label what American’s idolize, using many examples of free-roaming spirits. In lines six through eight, “Our Promised Land has always been over the next ridge or at the end of the trail…” the description of landscape exemplifies visual imagery, as well as in lines ten through thirteen “If we fish out a stream or wear out a field, or is the smoke from a neighbor’s chimney begins to crowd the sky...” Syntax can be seen in line seventeen when the normal subject, verb, object order is rearranged to add emphasis the message of the sentence “stand still, we are warned, and you die.” Diction, also known as word choice, is very negative when referring to the constant moving and relocating of Americans, words like “unglamorous” “dead-end” “imposing” “force” “disastrous” “devastated” are used throughout the passage. The tone, which is the use of all of the other four elements, is very criticizing towards American’s nature to move and settle somewhere new constantly. The use of diction when describing these settlements has a negative connotation, with words such as “dead-end” “”ugly” “trapped.” Also, the …show more content…

In lines fifty through fifty-two, Sanders uses a cultural belief to contradict yet make a connection to a quote from Rushdie in the previous lines: “But the migrants often pack up their visions and values with the rest of their baggage and carry them along.” It is his cultural belief about the immigrants as they ventured to the new world, where the restlessness comes from. Another cultural belief is presented in lines seventy-three through seventy-five “People who root themselves in places are likelier to know and care for those places rather than are people who root themselves in ideas.” Sander’s expresses his beliefs about a culture of people who stay put, rather than a culture of people who constantly move, which in connection to Rushdie contradicts his enthusiasm for migration. Sanders states in response to Rushdie’s beliefs “Everything about us is mongrel; from race to language, and we are stronger for it.” which his belief about our culture as a whole, that although was are inharmonious, we are better for it, which agrees with Rushdie “the transformation that comes of new and unexpected combinations of human beings, cultures, ideas, politics, movies, songs.” Sanders uses cultural relationships to make connections with the Rushdie and the ways in which their beliefs differ and are

Get Access