1. How would you describe the ethical dilemma confronted by the managers at the law firm? The ethical dilemma was choosing either to respect Andrew’s condition or to take care of the health and interests of the rest of the employees. The latter option meant that Andrew had to be dismissed due his condition (suffering from a deadly disease and being homosexual). The ethical dilemma arose because the company had to compromise other factors and make a decision of firing Andrew based on others requests. They chose to leave aside his services as an amazing lawyer, thought that by doing so, they would be isolated from contagion of HIV. 2. Are the managers at Wyant & Wheeler justified in firing Andrew? What set of criteria would you use to arrive at this decision? No. The managers at Wyant and Wheeler were not justified to fire Andrew. Andrew, being a brilliant lawyer knew that it was his legal right to keep his HIV status secret to himself. The firm’s main reason for firing Andrew was because of panic. The managers feared the deadly disease. However, they discriminated against Andrew by firing him merely because of his condition. Instead of firing Andrew, the managers should have adopted a better way of protecting the rest of the employees from contracting the disease. 3. How is the fact that Andrew concealed his illness relevant to the case? The fact that Andrew concealed his illness is relevant to the case because of the worries he had about the stigmas. He
The purpose of this paper is to examine an ethical dilemma faced by a company who manufactures critical components for a pacemaker developer. The consequentialist ethical theory of utilitarianism will be used to evaluate the moral implications this company has in continuing further manufacturing for their pacemaker client. An overview of utilitarian ethics will be discussed, focused primarily around 17th century philosopher Jeremy Bentham’s ideas about ethics. His framework will be used to present factors that influence the transistor company’s business decision. Finally, the Utility Test and Common Good Test will be applied to the company’s predicament to help determine the correct ethical course of action for this
Unethical practices of business managements are also tough for the employees who get confused whether to do what is right or just avoid complications and go with the flow. Solomon states that
An ethical dilemma occurs when a person is forced to choose between two or more alternatives, none which is ideal (Finkelman & Kenner, 2014). In the film WIT, the major ethical dilemma presented in the film, were the treatment option that were offered to her by the physician. The physician manipulated the situation when he informs professor Barrings of her terminal cancer in its advance stages. Not given the time to process her diagnosis, the physician continues to talk about an experimental chemotherapy treatment as if it were her only option,
Describe the conflict faced by corporate insiders who discover unethical or illegal activities within their organization.
In beginning my research assignment on the paralegal profession and its impact on ethics, I recalled the information that I learned from Chapter 8 Online Search Techniques: Learning the Methods in the “Legal Research and Writing for Paralegals” textbook. Prior to my search commencing I recalled from Chapter 9 that the most common URL suffixes are .com, .org, .net, .gov, and.edu; but to use my best judgment to determine the accuracy and reliability of a Web site. I learned that search engines provide the link to the Internet or World Wide Web. This process assisted me in gathering information based upon a given set of search terms. I performed a key word search using the Google search engine. Google provides general and advanced searches with an extensive database. I entered in the query “paralegal ethics.” I avoided using the noise word “and” by placing a space between two words which is automatically considered “and” on Google.com. Of the 649,000 results I used the first result from www.nala.org/code.aspx. This was the website of NALA, the National Association of Legal Assistants. “NALA Code of Ethics and Professional Responsibility” was first adopted by the NALA in May of 1975. It is the foundation of ethical practices of paralegals in the legal community. The performance of the duties of a paralegal are governed by specific canons as defined in NALA Code of Ethics and Professional Responsibility so that justice will be served and goals of the profession attained. The
The ethical issues and dilemma described in this chapter is a conflict of interest where there is a romantic interest between Jackie and her future manager. Next is sexual harassment and verbally abused by the manager. And discrimination where she is asking help from the legal department but because she doesn't have enough evidence to prove that the manager abused her.
Ethical theory will be outlined in relation to the example case with discussion on how the case poses an ethical dilemma in the workplace. Additionally ethical theory will be considered in light of the case with
The problem to be investigated is the application of business ethics. In the business world, ethics are extremely important. Ethics are prime elements that help a business to grow and to become more productive. It is by applying proper business ethics that a business can operate in a moral or ethical business environment and managed to conduct all activities in a manner that maximizes profits while not compromising all other non-economic concerns(Schwab, 1996). Businesses have over the years failed to nurture business ethics in order to fulfill shareholders' interests and to have a culture that is oriented towards profit maximization and high performance(Jennings, 2012; Sims & Felton, 2006). This has led business to have gray areas in their activities. Gray areas are those situations or problems that do not fit exactly into any ethical analysis. These are the activities which may be represented to be immoral as a result of lying and false representations on the part of the business.
There is a certain level of ethics in relation to the practice of law with being an attorney. While I was a freshman in college, a professor who is also a former detective was testifying in a murder trial of a 13 year-old-girl. I decided I would attend the trial because I was curious of what it would be like and it was also open to the public. I saw both counsels arguing passionately – each seemingly convinced of the rectitude of his own arguments and in the outrageousness of the other’s positions. Perhaps naïvely, my first reaction was to question the defendant 's attorney. How could he represent an individual he must have known to be guilty of murder? How could he consciously endeavor to deprive the victim 's family of the truth? Even then, I understood that the law requires that every individual, irrespective of circumstance, be entitled to proper representation and that such a commitment is necessary to ensure liberty and due process of law. Nonetheless, I had my reservations. A careful analysis of the relationship between ethics and the law provided me some clarity.
It is a relevant ethical dilemma because it is a situation in which an ethical decision needs to be made by a businessman (CFO of Gabriel Resources) where viable options to this case are available which will be judged further in this essay by applying ethical theory and concepts.
The ethical dilemma is a situation by which it’s difficult to determine whether a situation is can be handled without disappointing both sides. Therefore, an ethical dilemma exists when the right thing to do is clear or when members of the healthcare team cannot agree on the right thing to do. Ethical dilemmas require negotiation of different points of view (potter, Perry, Stockert, & Hall 2011pg 78).
It is relevant, before discussing professional codes of practice, to briefly introduce some of the
The ethical dilemma Bob faces in this case is a transaction that makes Bob question his and the company’s ethics and legal obligations. It’s February, business was slow, the company was $5,000 below their breakeven point, and it appeared as if a
Using 2 different companies as example, analyse and evaluate the ethical decision making process within a business setting.
The inherent ethical dilemma that presents itself in this case is whether or not it is ethical to cut corners to make a profit. The management is aware of the issue, yet continues to allow the defective drives to be sold in order to attempt to appease the company’s new CEO. Is it ethical for a company to sell a defective product in order to avoid loss?