The city of Winnipeg has enacted a bylaw intended to curb prostitution in that city. The new bylaw provides that individuals engaged in prostitution may face fines of up to $5000 and imprisonment of up to six months. Could the bylaw withstand constitutional scrutiny? Question 21 options: A As long as the city was acting within its powers under the Manitoba Municipal Act¸ the bylaw will likely withstand constitutional scrutiny. B The bylaw would likely be seen as an attempt of a municipality to enact a criminal law and would be unconstitutional because criminal law falls under federal jurisdiction. C As long as the federal government does not object¸ the bylaw is within the city's legal jurisdiction. D As long as the provincial government does not object¸ the bylaw is within the city's legal jurisdiction.
The city of Winnipeg has enacted a bylaw intended to curb prostitution in that city. The new bylaw provides that individuals engaged in prostitution may face fines of up to $5000 and imprisonment of up to six months. Could the bylaw withstand constitutional scrutiny? Question 21 options: A As long as the city was acting within its powers under the Manitoba Municipal Act¸ the bylaw will likely withstand constitutional scrutiny. B The bylaw would likely be seen as an attempt of a municipality to enact a criminal law and would be unconstitutional because criminal law falls under federal jurisdiction. C As long as the federal government does not object¸ the bylaw is within the city's legal jurisdiction. D As long as the provincial government does not object¸ the bylaw is within the city's legal jurisdiction.
Related questions
Question
The city of Winnipeg has enacted a bylaw intended to curb prostitution in that city. The new bylaw provides that individuals engaged in prostitution may face fines of up to $5000 and imprisonment of up to six months. Could the bylaw withstand constitutional scrutiny?
Question 21 options:
| A | As long as the city was acting within its powers under the Manitoba Municipal Act¸ the bylaw will likely withstand constitutional scrutiny. |
| B | The bylaw would likely be seen as an attempt of a municipality to enact a criminal law and would be unconstitutional because criminal law falls under federal jurisdiction. |
| C | As long as the federal government does not object¸ the bylaw is within the city's legal jurisdiction. |
| D | As long as the provincial government does not object¸ the bylaw is within the city's legal jurisdiction. |
Expert Solution
This question has been solved!
Explore an expertly crafted, step-by-step solution for a thorough understanding of key concepts.
Step by step
Solved in 4 steps
