preview

Critical Thinking

Good Essays

In the book “Asking the Right Questions, A Guide to Critical Thinking” M. Neil Browne and Stuart M. Kelley discuss the ten steps to critical thinking. In the following pages I will apply these steps to a memo that was sent to Mr. Robert Shaw of Triad Insurance Company of Indianapolis and discuss them in detail. The memo was from Ms. Denise Khali, Vice President of Human Resources. D. Khali, personal communication, October 04, 2010. Step 1: What are the issues and conclusions? The major issue discussed in the memo is that Ms. Khali does not agree with the training ideas that have been presented by Mr. Clarke, Director of Operations. She goes into detail in her memo discussing the reasons why she feels the training program is …show more content…

If she was going to go with height as a supporting factor for her argument she shouldn’t have used these 3 leaders as examples within her memo. Another fallacy to this is stating that Mr. Clarke is short and is the only short leader in the company and that is the reason he wants to implement the training. She is trying to distract the reader from the main point of the memo. The most apparent fallacy within the memo is in the last paragraph when Ms. Khali states that Mr. Clarke is trying to discredit her personally by pushing the theories of the Aspen Institute. In this statement she is attempting to deter the reader from her original reasons why the training isn’t necessary and insinuate that there is a personal issue underlying why Mr. Clarke recommended the training to begin with. She is taking the memo to a personal level when she uses this statement. In the beginning she sites reasons why the company shouldn’t pursue the training but then in the end interjects a personal statement like that, it can be very misleading and confusing for the reader. Step 6: How good is the evidence? The evidence that was provided in this memo is very unsupportive of the arguments that she was trying to convey. Within her memo she is jumping all over the place and hitting on too many topics without honing in on one specific problem and expanding on

Get Access