preview

Independence in Updike’s A&P and Welty’s Why I Live at the P.O.

Decent Essays

Why do many strive to become independent or just do something bigger in life? With Updike’s “A&P” and Welty’s “Why I Live at the P.O.”, we get a first person look into two similar but different people’s lives and struggles. In “Why I Live at the P.O.” sister is the main character and the narrator. The same is for “A&P” but Sammy is the main character and narrator. Sammy and Sister throughout the stories battle with their want of being independent. Sister is jealous of her younger sister Stella-Rondo’s life from the beginning saying “She always had anything in the world she wanted and then she’d throw it away” (Welty 261). Like sister Sammy was always in search for a way to become independent or his own person in life. Sammy though …show more content…

Sammy gets a glimpse of independence from queenie when she buys her mother’s crackers. As Sammy thinks of queenie with her herring snacks he imagines “queenies parents standing around eating and drinking only the best things in life” (Updike 288). This imagery shows how desperate Sammy is at becoming independent to be his own person. All of his fantasies are crushed when the girls are told to leave and Sammy tries to stand up and say “I quit “(Updike 289). Shocking one of his family’s longtime friends the store manager, and also not even getting the girl of his dreams. Sammy finds himself stuck without a job because of his unthoughtful outburst. While Sammy may have gained independence he lost thing in life to help him be more independent. His impulsive uneducated action made him loose a job and have to deal with things more on his own since his parents got him that job. With A&P Sammy acted more on impulse and not thinking through his plan. This leaves him independent from his job but not really independent in the since that he really wanted. With Sammy losing his job it really shows the reader that irrational and unplanned decisions may sound best but they aren’t. Most cases it is the one like Sister that will turn out better in their decisions because of how when they did separate and become independent they had it planed out so that they knew what they wanted and get it. Sister’s approach to becoming independent was best way to go

Get Access